BristolBloggerGate: It’s just a typical n00b mistake!

So, thanks to radio journalist Martin Jones and news website Bristol 24/7 we now know that the reason for WordPress’s fritzing of The Bristol Blogger today was due to pressure from ex-University of the West of England vice-chancellor Sir Howard Newby. It seems he didn’t like some reference or other made by TBB. The word ‘defamation’ seems to have been thrown around. TBB is back up now, but WordPress has said the offending references must be gone by daybreak (or something similar).

Still, it makes you wonder exactly what it was that earned the takedown…

Whilst the blog posts in question appear to have been taken down, they can still be viewed via caches. One post, dated 26th May 2007, mentions a “private sector training company” in which both Sir Howard and his wife Lady Sheila held an interest being brought in to work with UWE. Another, from 7th July 2007, reflects on Sir Howard’s departure from UWE for pastures new at Liverpool University and again refers to the Newbys’ involvement with private consultants hired to work at UWE.

Similar points have been raised elsewhere – including the WordPress-hosted blogs Sir Howard Newby Watch and EcoLogics. However, the former appears to have been suspended in the same way as TBB was, and the latter’s blog post about the Newby-connected consultancy going into administration now throws up a 404 error message, consistent with a blog post that has been deleted (such as the Newby posts on TBB deleted under pain of blog deletion). Again, all the missing material is accessible through a cache search. Bizarrely, a different blog post on EcoLogics goes into greater detail about the Newbys involvement in private consultancy at UWE (and Sir Howard’s management style and educational philosophy) than the mysteriously missing post. Additionally, an independently-hosted blog, DC’s Improbable Science, carries similar material but remains up and running.

Outside of the blogosphere, mention is made of all the salient points in reports by the likes of Private Eye, The Guardian, Times Higher Education and others. The THE story refers to a different “private consultancy used by UWE during Sir Howard’s leadership…used by Liverpool for ‘work associated with strategic planning'”.

So what exactly was the beef with The Bristol Blogger (and Sir Howard Newby Watch, and possibly EcoLogics)? Is there something in the scandal pipeline that someone, somewhere, is trying to preemptively draw attention away from?

8 responses to “BristolBloggerGate: It’s just a typical n00b mistake!

  1. Ex-UWE academic Derek Wall has included some useful links to other Newby articles on his (non-WordPress!) blog. A commenter there has also added links to other related EcoLogics blog posts.

  2. I notice that a blog containing the following ‘Howard Newby, Higher Education’s Dr Beeching, has been stopped. leave a comment ». Howard Newby is to Higher Education in the early 21st century what Richard Beeching was to our country’s railways in the 1960s’ has also disappeared, credit where credit is due to Martin Jones….the rest of us with blogs need to keeping on blogging about Sir Howard.

  3. It’s why everyone should go self-hosted, especially with WordPress you could export your database, and be up with the offending posts in almost no time.

    It’s far too easy to DMCA Blogger, WordPress (hosted) and other hosted blogs, of course they can go bother your webhost but it’s a lot harder and webhosts won’t automatically take down content unless it’s obviously obscene or violating. They will usually ask first, and can’t easily remove posts anyway.

    Also you can run plugins backing up your database regularly, which means in a takedown you can be up with a new host in a day or two. Also good to have domain and webhost separate.

  4. thebristolblogger

    The original Eye story is on Facebook:

  5. For some reason that link now redirects to the Facebook front page… Curious!

  6. Pingback: Howard and me « The Bristol Blogger

  7. Pingback: BristolBloggerGate: Backlash against WordPress censorship builds up head of steam over Sir Howard Newby takedowns « Bristle’s Blog from the BunKRS

  8. Pingback: BristolBloggerGate: Three years on – the University of Liverpool, WordPress & censorship | Bristle's Blog from the BunKRS

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s